11 Jul 2007

Aral Speaks at max Pigs Flying

Yes, it's true, I'm speaking at MAX 2007 this year. But why, after being so vocally against their policies in the past? Simple. Because Adobe listened and they're making an effort to change, starting with the MAX conferences this year.

My criticism of MAX in the past centered around three things:

  1. They didn't pay speaker's expenses.
  2. You couldn't choose your own topic to present.
  3. It felt too much like a sales event that ignored the community.

This year, I'm happy to say, they've addressed all three of my concerns.

To qualify the first point a little further, it's important to realize that there are two types of speakers at events like these: Corporate and community.

Corporate speakers are there to evangelize their products. They may be Adobe Evangelists or evangelists from partner companies. Their sessions are usually product-based and showcase their latest and greatest features. When done right, i.e., when the speaker doesn't come off like a used car salesman, I personally find these sessions very valuable. I attended a couple such sessions during Adobe Live and learned quite a few things about the latest version of Photoshop.

Community speakers, on the other hand, are a very different group. They're not there to sell you a product but to share their experiences, knowledge, and, hopefully, inspire you. I remember how sessions by Branden and Joshua at the very first Flashforward conference I attended ages ago inspired me to learn more about Flash and get involved with the Flash community. A single inspirational session by a great speaker can easily make attending a conference worthwhile for me. In recent times, I've attended just such amazing sessions by Ze Frank, John Maeda, Jeremy Keith, Mario Klingemann, Brendan Dawes, Erik Natzke, Seb Lee Delisle, John Grden and Chris Allen, Keith Peters, Chris Orwig, and others. These are the sessions that energize me, widen my horizons, and inspire me to create things. In other words, they're invaluable.

One major difference between corporate and community speakers is that while corporate speakers are on company time when presenting at these events, earning their salaries and expensing their accounts, community speakers (for the most part) are not (some community speakers do work for companies like Yahoo! and Google who do pay their expenses, which is fair enough). One of my major beefs with MAX in the past was that it wouldn't pay for community speaker's expenses. This year, things have begun to change in this area and they are covering expenses for a select group of community speakers, including myself. I see this as a very positive step forward.

To put this into perspective, Adobe is a billion dollar company and yet they're listening to community feedback. As a comparison, Apple doesn't pay speakers to present at MacWorld. Do you think any amount of criticism by the community would get them to listen and change their policy on this? (The most I would expect is a fanboy response stating "Apple doesn't owe you anything!") *ducks* :)

The other issue I had with MAX was that you were pretty much asked to speak on a given topic and present the same (often product-related) session several times. In other words, it felt like you were being employed to be a corporate speaker when, in fact, you weren't even being employed. This year, with the "inspire" line of sessions, that's changing too. I'm going to be presenting the latest version of my Rediscovering Fun session and talking about SWX. At MAX. That rocks! :)

This year's MAX is going to be the first one that embraces the amazing community Adobe has around its products and all I can say is, it was about time! I believe that Adobe is finally realizing that the Flash community is far more than a loose conglomeration tied together by commercial interests: It's a living, breathing, passionate family of designers and developers who truly love working on this amazing platform. Among other things, it feels like Adobe has finally begun to realize that this community is one of the things that sets it apart from the purely corporate, follow-the-bucks community that Microsoft has. (Microsoft does an amazing job of building an economy around its products but the monetary incentive is almost entirely the only thing that binds people to it -- not so with the Flash community.)

So is this a clever short-term PR move on Adobe's part or are they truly committed to involving the community in MAX and other Adobe events? There are several strong indicators I've seen that point to the latter.

Firstly, Adobe must be aware of the wonderful feedback Adobe Live Amsterdam got for its Developer Track this year. I was personally floored by the positive feedback my sessions got and I know that the other developer sessions were held in similarly high esteem. At about the same time, Adobe Live in the UK, with an expanded designer and developer track, also got very favorable reviews. The message from this is clear: Involving the community in these events is a winning formula.

Secondly, my good friend Ted Patrick has been tasked with heading up preparations for MAX this year. Ted is one my oldest Flash buddies and has been in the Flash community for as long as I can remember. He's a Flash developer that I both admire and respect and, most importantly, coming from the community, he understands the community. Putting Ted in charge of MAX is a clear signal from Adobe that they want MAX to have a much stronger community focus.

Personally, I am very excited about MAX this year and I want to thank my friends at Adobe for listening and for taking those most important first steps towards changing things.

Here's to the best MAX conferences ever in Chicago, Barcelona and Japan! (I'm especially looking forward to Japan as it will be my first time there and I've been dying to go for ages!) :)

Creative Commons LicenseThe I’m speaking at MAX? WTF? article by Aral Balkan, unless otherwise expressly stated, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 2.0 UK: England License.

Add Your Comment

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree

I’m speaking at MAX? WTF?

  1. Good to hear you’ll be presenting your sessions at MAX, didn’t think I’d see the day when that’d happen ;)

    I had the same reservations as yourself and think Adobe is making good progress in addressing the issues for community speakers.

    Peter
  2. you’re going to Japan!

    *weeps with jealousy*

    Relly
  3. Okay, I’ll take the bait. MacWorld is an expo put on by IDG. Not the same as the MAX situation. WWDC would probably be closer, but even that event is not exactly the same as MAX in tone and purpose. If you really want to speak at MacWorld and want the corp to pay your way, speak with IDG.

    Matt
  4. How many community speakers are within the “select group”? I have to say, these 2 sentences don’t come off particularly well:

    “This year, things have begun to change in this area and they are covering expenses for a select group of community speakers, including myself. I see this as a very positive step forward.”

    So, where does the line of principle get drawn here? When your expenses are covered?

    hmmm
  5. @Matt: You’re right, WWDC would be closer.

    I did actually speak at MacWorld this year thanks to Lynda (FlashForward had a track there) and it was loads of fun. But I wouldn’t have paid to present :)

    Aral
  6. @hmmm:

    So, where does the line of principle get drawn here? When your expenses are covered?

    Basically, yes. I don’t know enough about the arrangements they have with other speakers to go out on a limb there (will they cover the expenses of a Yahoo! employee, for example, etc.) I do know that they are making an effort to change and that this is the first step they’ve taken. I find that the step is a positive one and I plan to support that step.

    Based on the success of this year (and I’m sure it *will* be successful), I’m sure they will move further along in the same direction.

    Aral
  7. We are providing hotel for all speakers at MAX and paying travel for “Inspire” speakers at MAX to sure the MAX conference is amazing.

    Aral, I am glad you are speaking at MAX. Thanks for your kind words here.

    Adobe MAX is going to be different this year. I am focused on making it the best ever. We have an amazing community and refocusing the conference on the community the right choice long term. I look forward to seeing everyone at MAX 2007!

    More to come!

    Ted Patrick
    Adobe Systems

    Ted Patrick
  8. Aral, when you say you’re speaking at MAX you mean all three MAXs? Wow and well done (I may see you at one of them).

    Stefan Richter
  9. @Ted: Thanks, man, looking forward to them!

    @Stefan: Yep, all three :) (Thanks!) Can’t wait for Japan especially.

    Aral
  10. Whilst trying to avoid becoming number one Adobe fan boy … great to hear they’re not being greedy corporate piggies :-)

    Space Monki
  11. OK looks very cool.

    Can we connect remotely to a Coldfusion service? I would be glad to help if this isn’t in play.

    John Farrar
  12. I view Aral’s passion for calling out Adobe (and mine, though I don’t mean to tag along too much here) is simply a matter of caring about their products. Adobe, too, has great people–Ted being just one of them. I don’t mean to sound patronizing, but I don’t want people to think we’re (and again I don’t mean to speak for Aral) out to get Adobe… in fact, that wouldn’t make much sense.

    Anyway, I also like the definitive specification of the reimbursement rules. I don’t think it made much sense the way Aral first stated it–I mean it sounded like all “regular” speakers were just there to push some product–which they’re not (hopefully). I’d think, too, that some speakers MIGHT actually get paid–I mean, taking it to an extreme, I think that Verizon dude musta gotten something and blue-man-group. But, seriously, sometimes big name speakers SHOULD be paid.

    Whatever… I’m psyched a little more than usual. UCON and MAX have always been pretty darn good conferences. Both the momentum in the new products and the new MAX evangelist (Ted) should make for a good time. Oh, and having Aral there too!

    Phillip Kerman
  13. Wheres the one in Europe this year ?

    pete
  14. @pete: Barcelona — one of my favorite cities! :)

    Aral
  15. [...] (What, Aral’s presenting at MAX?) [...]

    SWX World Tour at Aral Balkan